Best Pizza in Tallahassee

Your Go-To Spot For Hot From The Oven Pizzas & Crowd-Ready Favourites

Order online

Featured

View menu

We Are Located in Tallahassee

Our Governors Square Blvd location at 1505 Governors Square Blvd STE 2, Tallahassee is set in a busy commercial area with nearby shopping centers, offices, and residential communities. Whether you’re coming from Midtown, Southwood, or surrounding neighborhoods, Five Star Pizza is easy to access.

Find Us

Welcome To Five Star Pizza

Address: 1505 Governors Square Blvd STE 2, Tallahassee, FL 32301, United States Phone: +1 850-361-3661 Hours: Everyday: 11 AM–3 AM

Get Directions

Bold Oven Creations That Call Your Name

Imagine pulling apart warm slices straight from the oven, each one layered with rich sauces and melty goodness that glows under the lights. Crispy edges, soft centers, and a playful medley of textures make every mouthful an irresistible experience. Perfect for sharing with crew, celebrating wins, or just treating yourself — this is comfort turned up a notch.

Explore Our Menu

Fast, Fresh, and Delicious Game-Day Pizza

Tallahassee locals and college students love Five Star Pizza for serving up hot, fresh comfort food exactly when they need it. The general community consensus highlights our thick, cheesy slices, signature cheesy sticks, and legendary garlic rolls as absolute must-order items. The local sentiment centers on incredibly quick delivery drivers, great price points, and a highly efficient staff dedicated to keeping your delivery piping hot for game day.

Order From Our Website

Craving it now? Skip the wait and order directly from our website for delivery or easy pickup. Get hot, fresh favorites heading your way with just a few clicks — the way your evening was meant to be enjoyed.

Order Now

Our Gallery

Browse our gallery and see what’s coming out of the oven every cheesy layer, every crispy crust, and every moment that looks this good.

Need Catering That Everyone Will Love?

Take the stress out of your event with shareable options made to please groups of any size. Simple ordering, reliable service, and food that brings people together.

Get Catering Info

A Place For Everyone

From solo visits to group hangouts, everyone feels welcome here. Whether you’re here for a quick bite, a late-night treat, or a relaxed meal with friends, our doors are open and the oven’s always fired up. Come as you are, stay as long as you like.

Visit Us Today!! 🍕

Stop by and enjoy freshly prepared favorites served hot and ready. Our team is here daily to make your visit easy, quick, and enjoyable from the moment you arrive. Hours: Mon - Sun: 11:00 AM – 3:00 AM

What our guests are saying

I have been ordering pizza from Fivestar for my staff at work for the past 3 years. The staff at Five Star has always been professional, fast and friendly. The food has always been consistent, quality and freaking Delicious! Helps us power thru busy times, to meet those deadlines.

Kevin W.

Best chain pizza restaurant in Tallahassee! They use real Wisconsin cheese and other high quality ingredients. The team is great and has been mostly the same for many many years, which tells you everything you need to know. The employees are courteous and respectful. I have never received the wrong order or had any issue whatsoever. If you want, great quality pizza, this is the place!

Casey S.

Never been disappointed! Pizzas arrived piping hot, and exactly as ordered. Delivery dude was great as well! Highly recommend! And if you’re out of delivery zone, it’s well worth the drive to pick up!!