Welcome To Five Star Pizza
Visit us in Sarasota on Bee Ridge Road or in Tallahassee on Governors Square Boulevard for fresh oven-baked favorites, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere built for every occasion. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch, picking up dinner after work, or stopping by for late-night bites, both locations serve bold flavors and satisfying meals made fresh throughout the day.
Bold Oven Creations That Call Your Name
Imagine pulling apart warm slices straight from the oven, each one layered with rich sauces and melty goodness that glows under the lights. Crispy edges, soft centers, and a playful medley of textures make every mouthful an irresistible experience. Perfect for sharing with crew, celebrating wins, or just treating yourself — this is comfort turned up a notch.
Order From Our Website
Craving it now? Skip the wait and order directly from our website for delivery or easy pickup. Get hot, fresh favorites heading your way with just a few clicks — the way your evening was meant to be enjoyed.
Our Gallery
Browse our gallery and see what’s coming out of the oven every cheesy layer, every crispy crust, and every moment that looks this good.
Need Catering That Everyone Will Love?
Take the stress out of your event with shareable options made to please groups of any size. Simple ordering, reliable service, and food that brings people together.
A Place For Everyone
From solo visits to group hangouts, everyone feels welcome here. Whether you’re here for a quick bite, a late-night treat, or a relaxed meal with friends, our doors are open and the oven’s always fired up. Come as you are, stay as long as you like.
Visit Us Today!! 🍕
Stop by and enjoy freshly prepared favorites served hot and ready at our Sarasota and Tallahassee locations. Whether you're grabbing a quick lunch, dinner with friends, or a late-night bite, our team is here daily to make every visit easy, quick, and enjoyable.
Hours: Mon – Sun: 11:00 AM – 3:00 AM
What our guests are saying
The staff was so friendly. Garlic bread was the best I've had, that is no lie. The pizza was scrumptious! And can't forget the cinnamon roll for dessert that was out of this world. If you pass this place up. You are making a big mistake!
Raymond K.
I tell everyone Five Star is the best delivery pizza in the SRQ area. The big chains (dominoes, Pizza Hut even hungry howies) are all awful compared to five star. I also appreciate that 5 star isn’t overly salty like the others!! Amazing pizza keep it up!!
Thomas
Another great Sarasota restaurant! Had Five Star delivered tonight (so that we could enjoy them on the beach). On time and fresh. Staff was friendly. Sauce is delicious and crust cooked perfectly. The plain cheese pizza was very good. I recommend their version of a meat lovers pizza. Generous toppings and not greasy like alot of pizzas topped heavily with meats.
Troy D.
Featuring
Delivery
Takeout
Catering
Dine In
Five Star Pizza Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!
Frequently Asked Questions
What are you known for?
We are known for Caesar Salad, Gluten Free Food, Hawaiian Pizza, Gluten Free, Wings, Veggie Pizza, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Cheese Pizza, Chicken Alfredo, Chicken Wings, Salads, and Greek Salad
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: Tallahassee, Sarasota Springs, Bee Ridge, Sunnyland, South Gate Ridge, Southgate, Ridge Wood Heights, Pinecraft, Fruitville, Perkins, Lafayette, South Trail, Lake Sarasota, South Sarasota, Gulf Gate Estates, Sarasota, Leon County, Saint Peter, Tatum, and Belair.
